Skip to main content

Why Motorcycle Injury Cases Often Go To Court

June 12, 2025

Posted in Uncategorized

Motorcycle accidents frequently lead to serious injuries, long recovery periods, and complicated insurance claims. While many personal injury matters settle outside of court, motorcycle-related claims often end up in litigation. According to a motorcycle accident lawyer, the reasons behind this are not always obvious but tend to involve disputes over liability, inadequate settlement offers, or the severity of injuries sustained.

Disagreements Over Fault Are Common

Motorcycle riders are often unfairly blamed for accidents, even when another driver was primarily responsible. This bias can make it difficult to reach an agreeable resolution early in the claims process. If the at-fault party refuses to accept liability or if the insurance company argues that the rider shared significant blame, it can lead to a courtroom battle. When the facts are disputed or there are no clear witnesses, it becomes even more difficult to resolve the case without going to trial.

Injury Severity Raises The Stakes

Motorcycle crashes often result in catastrophic injuries due to the lack of protection compared to passenger vehicles. Traumatic brain injuries, spinal damage, and multiple fractures are not uncommon. These types of injuries involve high medical expenses, loss of income, and long-term care needs. Insurance companies may push back on paying the full value of a claim, especially when the damages exceed policy limits or require future financial planning. Victims may be left with no option but to pursue litigation to recover a fair amount.

Low Settlement Offers Delay Resolution

Insurers often try to settle quickly and for less than what the claim is actually worth. When that happens, injured riders may feel pressured to accept offers that won’t come close to covering their needs. When a fair settlement isn’t offered, filing a lawsuit becomes the best route to achieve justice. Litigation puts pressure on the other side to reassess their position and consider the long-term consequences of going to trial.

Insurance Tactics Can Complicate Cases

Motorcycle injury claims are sometimes met with aggressive defense strategies, especially when large insurance carriers are involved. These companies may challenge medical treatment plans, question the credibility of the injured rider, or suggest the injuries are unrelated to the crash. Such tactics can stall negotiations and push a case further toward trial. When the defense becomes confrontational or unreasonable, court involvement may be necessary to protect the rider’s rights.

Jury Trials May Be Strategically Beneficial

In certain situations, the injured rider’s legal team may determine that a jury trial would result in a better outcome than settling. This may be due to public sympathy, strong evidence, or confidence in the ability to present a persuasive case. While no trial is guaranteed to succeed, taking the case to court can sometimes lead to a more favorable judgment than what was originally offered during settlement discussions.

Attorneys like those at our friends at Woron and Dhillon, LLC, can attest that when a motorcycle accident leads to life-altering injuries, litigation may be the most practical and effective way to pursue fair compensation. Especially in claims involving disputed liability, long-term medical care, or bad faith insurance practices, court proceedings provide a structured path toward resolution.

Motorcycle injury claims carry unique challenges, but injured riders don’t have to face them alone. If you or someone you know is dealing with the aftermath of a serious crash, it’s worth exploring every legal option. Motorcycle accident lawyers can help assess the situation and pursue the compensation that truly reflects the losses suffered.

Meet Bennett M. Cohen

San Francisco Personal Injury Attorney

Bennett M. Cohen brings over 30 years of litigation experience which includes representing plaintiffs against massive companies like the Shell Oil Company, Standard Insurance Company, and Metropolitan Life Insurance Company. Bennett M. Cohen brings an experienced and dynamic touch that separates himself from large law firms. He can oversee every aspect of your case, ensuring you receive specialized assistance.

Learn more

Meet Bennett M. Cohen

Don’t Leave Your Case To Chance

Ensure your case is in the hands of a seasoned professional that will fight for you