Posted in Uncategorized
The delivery truck that hit you has a company logo plastered across its side. The driver who caused your accident was working, making deliveries, running errands, or otherwise conducting business when the collision occurred. This changes your claim significantly because you might pursue compensation not just from the driver but from their employer, who likely has substantially more insurance coverage and deeper pockets than individual drivers.
Our friends at Brown Paindiris & Scott, LLP discuss how accidents involving company vehicles often provide better recovery prospects than crashes with personal vehicles. A truck accident lawyer can identify all liable parties including employers, determine available insurance coverage, and pursue maximum compensation through commercial policies that typically offer higher limits than personal auto insurance.
Employer Liability Through Respondeat Superior
Employers are legally responsible for their employees’ negligent actions when those employees are acting within the scope of employment. This legal doctrine called respondeat superior makes companies liable for accidents their employees cause while working.
The scope of employment includes any activity reasonably connected to the employee’s job duties. Driving to make deliveries, running work errands, traveling between job sites, or transporting equipment all fall within the scope of employment.
Even slight detours from direct work routes might still be within the scope of employment. Stopping for coffee on the way to a client meeting or taking a slightly longer route home from a delivery typically doesn’t remove the employee from the scope of their employment.
When Employers Aren’t Liable
Employees commuting to and from work in company vehicles are generally not acting within the scope of employment. The commute is considered personal time even when driving a company car.
Major deviations from work duties might break the employment connection. If an employee takes a company vehicle on a personal weekend trip and causes an accident, the employer might not be liable because the employee wasn’t furthering any business purpose.
Intentional criminal acts by employees typically fall outside the scope of employment unless the employer negligently hired someone with a known history of similar conduct or the job created opportunities for the criminal behavior.
Determining If The Driver Was Working
Vehicle markings provide clues about employment status. Clearly marked company vehicles strongly suggest the driver was working at the time of the accident. Logo-covered delivery vans, service trucks with business names, or vehicles with company license plates indicate employment.
The time of day matters. Accidents during normal business hours are more likely work-related than those occurring late at night or on weekends. However, many employees work nontraditional hours, so timing alone doesn’t determine employment status.
What the employee was doing when the accident occurred is the most important factor. Investigate whether they were making deliveries, traveling to job sites, running work errands, or otherwise conducting company business.
Commercial Auto Insurance Coverage
Companies typically carry commercial auto liability policies with much higher limits than personal auto insurance. While personal policies often have $25,000 to $100,000 in liability coverage, commercial policies commonly provide $500,000 to $1 million or more.
These higher limits mean you’re more likely to receive full compensation for serious injuries when companies are liable. The available coverage can actually pay for all your medical expenses, lost wages, and pain and suffering rather than being capped at inadequate policy limits.
Commercial policies also typically cover employees driving personal vehicles for work purposes. If the driver was using their own car to run a work errand when they hit you, the employer’s commercial policy might provide coverage beyond the driver’s personal insurance.
Umbrella Policies Provide Additional Coverage
Many companies carry umbrella liability policies providing additional coverage above their primary commercial auto policy limits. These excess policies can add millions of dollars in available coverage for serious accidents.
Umbrella coverage kicks in after primary policy limits are exhausted. If the commercial auto policy has $1 million in coverage and an umbrella policy provides an additional $2 million, you have access to $3 million total coverage for your injuries.
Multiple Liable Parties
You might pursue claims against both the employee driver and their employer. While typically you can’t double-recover for the same damages, having multiple defendants with separate insurance policies provides backup coverage if one source proves insufficient.
The employer’s liability doesn’t eliminate the employee’s personal liability. Both can be sued, though practically you’ll focus on the employer because they have better insurance coverage and more assets.
Negligent Hiring And Supervision
Beyond respondeat superior liability for employee negligence, employers can be directly liable for their own negligence in hiring, training, or supervising drivers. If the company hired someone with a terrible driving record, failed to conduct background checks, or ignored complaints about dangerous driving, this creates independent employer liability.
Employer negligence theories include:
- Hiring drivers with suspended licenses or drunk driving histories
- Failing to train employees properly for vehicles they operate
- Ignoring complaints about specific drivers’ unsafe practices
- Requiring unrealistic delivery schedules that encourage speeding
- Inadequately maintaining company vehicles
These direct negligence claims can be valuable when employee actions fall outside the scope of employment, providing alternative paths to employer liability.
Vehicle Maintenance Issues
Companies must maintain their vehicle fleets in safe operating condition. Brake failures, tire blowouts, or other mechanical problems caused by inadequate maintenance create employer liability separate from driver negligence.
Maintenance records become important evidence in company vehicle accidents. These documents show whether required inspections occurred, identified problems were addressed, and the vehicle was safe to operate at the time of the accident.
Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration regulations require commercial vehicle operators to maintain detailed maintenance records. Violations of these maintenance requirements support negligence claims against employers.
Independent Contractor Issues
Not every driver operating a vehicle with company branding is an employee. Many companies use independent contractors for deliveries and other services, complicating liability determinations.
True independent contractors are not employees, and respondeat superior doesn’t make companies liable for contractor negligence. However, many companies misclassify employees as contractors to avoid liability and employment taxes.
Courts examine the actual relationship to determine employee versus contractor status regardless of what the company calls the worker. Factors include who controls how work is performed, who provides equipment, whether the worker works for other companies, and how payment is structured.
Investigating Company Vehicle Accidents
Identifying the employer requires investigation beyond just seeing a company name on the vehicle. Some drivers place decals on personal vehicles, and contractors might use company branding without being employees.
Obtain the driver’s information at the scene including employer name and contact information. Photograph the vehicle showing company markings, vehicle identification numbers, and license plates.
Your attorney can investigate the employment relationship, obtain company information, and determine which entities might be liable for your injuries.
Claims Against Deep Pocket Defendants
Large companies present “deep pocket” defendants who can pay substantial judgments. Unlike individuals who might lack assets to satisfy judgments, companies typically have insurance and business assets that can pay significant damages.
This reality makes company vehicle accidents potentially more valuable than crashes with uninsured or underinsured individual drivers. The same injuries that might be uncompensated when caused by an uninsured driver become fully compensable when a company is liable.
The Claims Process Differences
Claims against companies involve different procedures than claims against individuals. You’ll deal with corporate insurance adjusters, company legal departments, and potentially multiple insurance layers.
Companies often respond more formally to claims with detailed investigations and legal involvement. They document everything carefully and defend aggressively, requiring professional representation to pursue claims effectively.
Time Limits For Company Claims
Standard statutes of limitations apply to most company vehicle accident claims. However, if the company is a government entity or the accident involves certain types of commercial vehicles, special notice requirements and shorter deadlines might apply.
Don’t assume you have years to file claims against companies. Some situations require much faster action to preserve your rights.
Preserving Electronic Evidence
Modern commercial vehicles often have GPS tracking, electronic logging devices, cameras, and other technology that records driver behavior. This electronic evidence can prove speeding, aggressive driving, or violations of hours-of-service regulations.
Your attorney should send preservation letters immediately after accidents demanding companies preserve all electronic data from the vehicle and driver. These systems often overwrite data quickly, and early action is necessary to prevent evidence loss.
Why Professional Representation Matters
Company vehicle accident claims involve corporate defendants with legal teams and significant resources to defend claims. These entities fight harder than individual defendants because substantial money is at stake and they want to limit precedents.
Going against corporate legal departments without professional representation puts you at a severe disadvantage. Companies know the law, understand insurance coverage intricacies, and employ tactics that unrepresented victims don’t recognize.
If you’ve been hit by a company vehicle and need help determining employer liability, identifying all available insurance coverage, or pursuing compensation from corporate defendants with substantial resources, reach out to discuss your situation and learn how to maximize recovery when companies are responsible for your injuries.
