Posted in Uncategorized
You were driving a rental car when another driver ran a stop sign and crashed into you. Now you’re dealing with the at-fault driver’s insurance, the rental company’s insurance, your personal auto insurance, your credit card company’s coverage, and possibly the rental agency’s damage waiver. Each entity is pointing fingers at the others about who should pay.
Our friends at Ausman Law Firm P.C., L.L.O. discuss how these accidents create layered insurance issues that don’t exist in typical car crashes. As a car accident lawyer will tell you, understanding which coverage applies and in what order prevents you from falling through the gaps while multiple insurance companies argue about responsibility.
The Rental Company’s Insurance Coverage
Rental car companies carry liability insurance that might cover you when you’re driving their vehicle. However, this coverage typically applies only when other available insurance is exhausted. The rental company’s policy serves as backup coverage, not primary protection.
The rental agreement you signed likely includes language making you responsible for damages and requiring you to provide your own insurance. This shifts the burden away from the rental company and onto your personal coverage or any optional protection you purchased.
Understanding the rental company’s policy limits and how their coverage interacts with other insurance requires careful review of both the rental agreement and their insurance policy terms.
Your Personal Auto Insurance
Most personal auto insurance policies extend coverage to rental vehicles. If you carry liability coverage, collision coverage, and comprehensive coverage on your own vehicle, those protections typically transfer to rental cars you drive.
This means your personal insurance becomes the primary coverage for both liability to others and damage to the rental vehicle. Your policy limits apply, and you’ll owe your normal deductible for any collision or comprehensive claims.
Some people assume renting a car means their personal insurance doesn’t apply. This misconception leads to purchasing unnecessary rental company coverage or worse, driving without adequate protection.
Credit Card Rental Car Coverage
Many credit cards offer rental car insurance as a cardholder benefit when you use the card to pay for the rental. This coverage typically applies to damage to the rental vehicle, not to liability for injuries or damage to other vehicles.
Credit card coverage usually serves as secondary insurance, meaning it covers gaps after your primary auto insurance pays. However, if you don’t carry collision coverage on your personal policy, credit card coverage might become primary for rental vehicle damage.
The coverage limits, exclusions, and claim procedures vary significantly between credit card companies. Some exclude certain vehicle types like trucks, luxury cars, or SUVs. Others limit coverage to specific rental periods or exclude international rentals.
The Rental Company Damage Waiver
When you rent a vehicle, the agent offers a collision damage waiver or loss damage waiver for a daily fee. This isn’t technically insurance but rather a contractual agreement where the rental company waives its right to collect damages from you if the vehicle is damaged.
Purchasing this waiver eliminates your financial responsibility for rental vehicle damage regardless of fault. Without it, you’re personally liable for repair costs up to the vehicle’s full value, subject to whatever insurance coverage you have.
The waiver doesn’t provide liability coverage for injuries to others or damage to other vehicles. It only protects you from the rental company’s property damage claims.
The At-Fault Driver’s Insurance
When another driver causes the accident, their liability insurance should pay for your injuries and the rental vehicle damage just like any other accident. This is where most injured people expect to recover compensation.
However, rental vehicle involvement sometimes complicates these claims. Insurance adjusters might question whether you were authorized to drive the rental, whether the rental agreement was valid, or whether you violated rental terms in ways that affect coverage.
The at-fault driver’s insurance company has no reason to care about the rental vehicle complications except as potential defenses to reduce their liability.
Insurance Priority And Coordination
Multiple insurance policies covering the same accident must coordinate through priority rules. Generally, the order of coverage is:
- The at-fault driver’s liability insurance for injuries and property damage to others
- Your personal auto insurance liability coverage if you were at fault
- Your personal auto insurance collision coverage for rental vehicle damage
- Credit card rental insurance as secondary coverage
- The rental company’s damage waiver if purchased
- The rental company’s insurance as excess coverage
Disagreements about this priority create disputes where each insurance company argues another policy should pay first.
Claims Against The At-Fault Driver
Your injury claim against the at-fault driver’s insurance proceeds normally regardless of rental vehicle complications. The fact that you were driving a rental rather than your own car doesn’t change the other driver’s liability for causing the accident.
However, property damage claims get more complicated. The rental company owns the damaged vehicle and has the legal right to claim compensation for repairs. They might file their own claim against the at-fault driver or require you to handle the property damage claim on their behalf.
Rental Company Subrogation Claims
Rental companies routinely pursue subrogation claims against at-fault drivers to recover vehicle damage costs. They have sophisticated claims departments that track accidents and file claims efficiently.
If you paid for damage to the rental vehicle through your insurance or out of pocket, the rental company might still pursue the at-fault driver independently and keep any recovery. This sometimes results in the rental company being made whole while you’ve already paid deductibles or damage costs.
When You’re At Fault In A Rental
If you caused the accident while driving a rental car, your personal auto insurance provides liability coverage for injuries and property damage to others. The rental company will bill you for vehicle damage unless you purchased their damage waiver.
Your collision coverage should pay for rental vehicle repairs subject to your deductible. If you lack collision coverage, you’re personally responsible for the full repair cost. Rental companies can and will sue customers for vehicle damage when insurance doesn’t pay.
Credit card rental coverage might cover damage you caused depending on the card’s terms. However, many credit card policies exclude coverage when the driver violated rental agreement terms or drove recklessly.
Rental Agreement Violations
Rental agreements contain restrictions about who can drive, where you can drive, and how you can use the vehicle. Violations can void insurance coverage and leave you personally liable for all damages.
Common violations include allowing unauthorized drivers to operate the vehicle, driving off-road or on unpaved roads, using the vehicle for commercial purposes, or crossing international borders without permission. Even letting a friend drive for a few minutes can void coverage if they’re not listed on the rental agreement.
Insurance companies scrutinize rental agreements after accidents looking for violations they can use to deny claims. Reading and following rental terms prevents these coverage disasters.
Business Rentals Vs. Personal Rentals
Vehicles rented for business purposes might be covered under commercial auto insurance policies rather than personal auto insurance. If your employer pays for the rental or you’re traveling for work, different insurance considerations apply.
Some personal auto policies exclude coverage for business use of rental vehicles. Understanding whether your rental qualifies as personal or business affects which insurance applies and whether you have coverage gaps.
International Rental Car Accidents
Accidents in rental cars outside the United States create additional complications. U.S. auto insurance policies often don’t extend coverage to foreign countries. Credit card rental protection might exclude international travel.
Foreign rental companies operate under different insurance laws and might not provide coverage comparable to U.S. standards. Purchasing local insurance becomes necessary but understanding what that insurance actually covers requires navigating foreign insurance regulations.
Long-Term Rentals
Insurance coverage can change for rentals exceeding certain durations, often 30 days. Some auto insurance policies limit rental vehicle coverage to shorter periods. Credit card benefits frequently cap coverage at 30 or 31 consecutive days.
Long-term renters need to verify their coverage remains in effect throughout the rental period and purchase additional protection if needed.
Diminished Value Claims
Rental companies sometimes claim diminished value when their vehicles are damaged and repaired. They argue the vehicle lost resale value even after proper repairs. These claims can add thousands to the damage amount beyond actual repair costs.
Who pays diminished value depends on the insurance coverage in place and whether the rental company purchased their damage waiver. These claims often become disputed issues requiring negotiation or litigation.
If you’ve been injured in an accident while driving a rental vehicle or you’re confused about which insurance companies should pay for injuries and damages, reach out to discuss how the multiple layers of coverage apply to your specific situation and how to coordinate claims between insurers to maximize your recovery without falling through coverage gaps.
